Friday, August 17, 2012

2012 Blow-Out the Budget Fantasy Football Draft Guide

            Instead of a month long mock draft, we’re going to cram all of No Credentials fantasy football draft advice into one column. Why you ask? Here are a couple reasons.

  1. Being the most popular fantasy sport, it lends itself to being the most unpredictable type of draft to predict. People draft more often based on personal bias, team allegiance, or a multitude of other reasons that have very little to do with statistical probability. You shouldn’t be shocked to end up in a draft where one person drafts “all Broncos” because that’s their favorite team.
  2. Fantasy football is the most luck driven fantasy sport. With the season being so short (compared with other leagues), all it takes is one torn ACL for your first round pick (see Jamaal Charles last season, or Tom Brady in 2008) and it’s over. You need an awful lot of things that aren’t in your control to go right in order for your team to win.
          With that said, if you’re invested enough, you can give yourself the best chance to win. I’m not going to say whether or not you should take Cam Newton or Tom Brady first, but instead we’re going to group players at different positions into tiers. It sounds complicated, but we’ll look at all the positions and then explain how tiers can help shape your draft strategy.



QB
Drew Brees
Aaron Rodgers
Cam Newton
Tom Brady
Michael Vick
Matthew Stafford
Eli Manning
Tony Romo
Philip Rivers
Matt Ryan
Jay Cutler
Peyton Manning
Ben Roethlisberger
Matt Schaub
Carson Palmer
Josh Freeman
Robert Griffin III
Joe Flacco
Andy Dalton
Ryan Fitzpatrick
Andrew Luck
Jake Locker
Matt Flynn
Mark Sanchez
Sam Bradford
Alex Smith
Matt Cassell
Christian Ponder


Tier 1 – These guys are the folks you will not take out of the starting lineup, regardless of who their opponent is. Regardless of which order you’d pick these guys in, they will all be off the board within the first 12 picks. You should not draft another quarterback if you pick one of these guys.

Tier 2 – Tier 2 consists of guys that have the potential to hit the Tier 1 level, but have a little more risk attached. Michael Vick was the top points per game producer in 2010, so his current average price (he’s going 44th in Yahoo! drafts) is worth it. Stafford is going at the price of a Tier 1, but I have my concerns. He’s only been healthy for one full season, and has a history of shoulder issues. Call me stubborn, but I want to see one more year of good health before I use a second round pick on Stafford. Manning and Romo are surprisingly similar (at least in the regular season), capable of single handedly winning and losing a week for your team. A backup quarterback can be picked as insurance in case of injury or a string of poor performances (although I wouldn’t recommend it), but you should not bench one of the Tier 2 players because your backup has a favorable match up.

Tiers 3 and 4 – Players who unless they establish trust, are best used in platoons. If the draft breaks right, you could grab two guys from these groups. For example, pairing Jay Cutler and Matt Ryan (currently going in the ninth and tenth rounds) makes a great deal of sense if you miss out on the first two tiers.

Tier 5 – This group is full of players who have too much unpredictability. Roethlisberger would be a Tier 3 if it weren’t for his “tiny little torn rotator cuff”. Schaub is an injury waiting to happen. Carson Palmer is a sneaky sleeper, but shouldn’t be drafted as your starter. Josh Freeman’s might have the largest gap between his ceiling and his floor.

Tier 6 –I’m pessimistic of RGIII, but will grant that his fantasy potential is greater than fellow rookie Andrew Luck. However, his slight build and lack of a go-to wide receiver (sorry Santana Moss fans) make me believe he will not duplicate Cam Newton’s 2011 season.

Tiers 7 and 8 – None of these guys should be drafted (unless you’re in a giant league, or a league that starts two QBs every week), but keep them in mind for bye weeks.



RB
Ray Rice
LeSean McCoy
Arian Foster
Chris Johnson
Darren McFadden
Matt Forte
Adrian Peterson
Trent Richardson
DeMarco Murray
Jamaal Charles
Maurice Jones-Drew
Ryan Matthews
Doug Martin
Marshawn Lynch
Fred Jackson
Steven Jackson
Reggie Bush
Michael Turner
Frank Gore
Darren Sproles
Beanie Wells
Ahmad Bradshaw
Willis McGahee
Jonathan Stewart
BenJarvus Green-Ellis
Roy Helu
Shonn Greene
Isaac Redman
Stevan Ridley
Jahvid Best
Donald Brown
James Starks
DeAngelo Williams
C.J. Spiller
Mark Ingram
Pierre Thomas
Ben Tate
Peyton Hillis
Ryan Williams
Toby Gerhart
Michael Bush
David Wilson
Jacquizz Rodgers
LeGarrette Blount
Felix Jones
Mikel LeShoure
Rashad Jennings
Joe McKnight
Daniel Thomas


Tier 1 – Here are the only three runningbacks I can sign off on as sure things (barring one unlucky blow to the ACL). Rice, McCoy, and Foster should never be benched regardless of opponent. Even against a stout run defense, all three backs are effective enough in the passing game to provide production. In some order, these three should be the first players off the board, regardless of scoring format.

Tier 2 – Every back in Tier 2 is capable of being top scoring fantasy runningback, but have some sort of question mark. Most are injury related, Chris Johnson is performance related (he’s only three years removed from a 2,000 yard season), and Maurice Jones-Drew is contract related. All of these backs need to be started when healthy. Tier 2 runningbacks will be off the board between the middle of the first through the end of the second round, and are the most likely players to sink your team.

Tier 3 and 4 – Players who have more question marks than Tier 2, with the added caveat that they are not automatic starts. Tier 3 backs can be drafted as your second runningback, while tier 4s are best served being no better than your third option.

Tier 5 – Here’s a group of backs that appear to have the inside track on playing time, but have never demonstrated before that they can handle a full workload. The only exception in this group is DeAngelo Williams, who hasn’t been a force since single-handedly deciding fantasy leagues in the 2008 fantasy playoffs.

Tier 6 – Backs with no immediate path to the majority of carries, but if they rose up to number one on the depth chart, would be viable fantasy starters. All of these players should be drafted as either handcuffs for your starters or lottery tickets. At least three of the Tier 6 backs will make a significant impact this season.



WR
Calvin Johnson
Larry Fitzgerald
Roddy White
A.J. Green
Andre Johnson
Victor Cruz
Brandon Marshall
Wes Welker
Hakeem Nicks
Greg Jennings
Mike Wallace
Steve Smith
Brandon Lloyd
Miles Austin
Julio Jones
Antonio Brown
Dez Bryant
Demaryius Thomas
Jordy Nelson
Marques Colston
Dwayne Bowe
Stevie Johnson
Percy Harvin
Eric Decker
Jeremy Maclin
Vincent Jackson
Kenny Britt
DeSean Jackson
Reggie Wayne
Pierre Garcon
Robert Meachem
Sidney Rice
Torrey Smith
Darrius Heyward-Bey
Denarius Moore
Justin Blackmon
Mike Williams
Malcolm Floyd
Santana Moss
Michael Crabtree
Greg Little
Anquan Boldin
Michael Floyd
Santonio Holmes
Laurent Robinson
Nate Burleson
Randy Moss
Lance Moore
Nate Washington
Mario Manningham
Davone Bess
Danny Amendola
Jon Baldwin


Tier 1 – The only two receivers in fantasy that are “quarterback proof”, meaning that they will still produce regardless of who is throwing too them. Both will be taken in the first round in 12-team leagues, with Megatron warranting consideration as a top pick in PPR leagues.

Tiers 2, 3, and 4 – All of these receivers can be targeted as your two starting wide receivers. There isn’t a great deal of difference between the second and fourth tiers, so consider that when you’re thinking about taking Roddy White in the second round.

Tiers 5 and 6 – Players that have had success in the past, but are either in new situations, or are boom or bust players (think 160 yards and two touchdowns or one catch for nine yards). I wouldn’t feel great about having one of these guys as my second wide receiver, but all of them have the potential to be top-10 fantasy producers.

Tier 7 – All of these guys should be drafted, but until they establish a track record of success, should be bye week options only.



TE
Jimmy Graham
Rob Gronkowski
Antonio Gates
Vernon Davis
Aaron Hernandez
Jermichael Finley
Jason Witten
Fred Davis
Jacob Tamme
Brandon Pettigrew
Jermaine Gresham
Tony Gonzalez
Brent Celek
Jared Cook
Owen Daniels
Coby Fleener
Dallas Clark
Greg Olsen
Tony Moeaki
Ed Dickson
Kyle Rudolph
Heath Miller
Kellen Winslow
Mercedes Lewis
Martellus Bennett
Todd Heap
Joel Dreessen
Anthony Fasano


Tier 1 – Graham and Gronkowski are in a class by themselves. I’d personally consider either of them at the end of the first if all the Tier 1 players at the other three positions were off the board.

Tier 2 – Antonio Gates is the only player that if healthy, is capable of delivering Tier 1 production. Similar to Michael Vick, he’s going in the middle of the fifth round in 10-team leagues, making him a potential league-swinging player.

Tier 3 – Solid, proven commodities that may not produce 12 receptions, 150 yards, and three touchdowns in a single game, but will be reliable sources of scoring week after week.

Tier 4 – Players that don’t have the track record of the Tier 3 group, but are also capable of being reliable weekly starters. Davis in particular is an intriguing player if you miss out on the top-end talent.

Tier 5, 6, and 7 – Best served as bye week substitutes (although one of these guys would have to start in a 12-team league).


            If you’re looking for defense and kicker rankings, you’ve come to the wrong place. Here are a few rules No Credentials has followed over the years (with a decent amount of success.

-         Don’t draft a kicker until the final round. If you do, you’re a dumbass (sorry, there’s no other way to word it).

-         Depending on your league scoring settings, it’s best to wait until the next to last round to snag a defense (I will only adjust this if the league I’m in awards extra points than usual for fewer points allowed). If you wait on defense, you can play the match-ups every week using the waiver wire. The value of hitting it big with a runningback you took in the ninth round is considerably greater than the value of a third ranked defense you could’ve taken at the same point. With that said…

-         Hoard runningbacks and wide receivers like they are canned fruit and the plague is about to hit. These are the positions where out of the blue breakouts are the most likely, and they also are the spots hit the hardest by injuries.

-         Only draft one tight end. It’s a really deep position this year, and the waiver wire will have plenty of options for you if you need to cover a bye or deal with an injury. Even if you draft a second tight end and he breaks out, you’ll have a very hard time moving him via trade because everyone else should have a solid one on his or her roster.

-         Before determining the number of players you need to take at each position, you need to understand the quality of players you have taken in the first six. Let’s assume you are building a 15-man roster. Three spots are going to be eaten up by a tight end, defense, and kicker (if you take a back-up at any of those positions, remember, you’re a dumb ass), so that leaves you 12 spots for three positions. If you end up with one of the Tier 1 or Tier 2 quarterbacks, you shouldn’t take a back up (use the waiver wire to find a QB with a favorable match-up in your starter’s bye week), giving you 11 spots to play with. If you’re first pick was Calvin Johnson, you should finish with four or five wide receivers drafted, and six or seven runningbacks. If Ray Rice was your first pick, you should flip that. Lastly, if you took a quarterback in the first round, you should aim for a six-five split between receiver and runningback.   

            Now it’s time to explain how tiers can be used to help plan your draft. At some point, you’ll eventually find out when you’re picking in the first round. Whether you have three weeks or 30 minutes, that’s plenty of time to figure out a strategy.
            As soon as you know where you are picking, you need to determine what your first priority is. For example, if you are dead set on landing a top tier runningback, you need to assess if that’s possible based on the average spot they are being taken (this info is available through both ESPN and Yahoo’s fantasy pages). Based on my tiers, I would probably need a top-3 pick to make this happen. If you decide you want Gronkowski or Graham, you know you need to snag them before the middle of the second. If you’re fine landing a second tier quarterback, you know you can draft one in the fifth or sixth rounds. In theory, it makes sense to wait as long as possible to grab the last player left in a given tier. For example, if there are three Tier 3 receivers left, and you have two of the next four picks, it’s wise to address another position before grabbing one of the receivers. Hell, if two of them are taken before you pick again, your decision is that much easier. 
           What would No Credentials ideal draft look like? I hate to be a politician, but that would all depend on where I’m picking and the size of the league. If I’m in an eight or ten team league, I’m waiting on quarterback. 12 or more teams, and I’m coming out with no worse than a Tier 2 QB. I’d really want one of the Tier 1 runningbacks, but if I don’t land a top-3 pick, would probably plan on drafting seven of them during the draft. The odds of me taking a Tier 1 tight end are slim, unless I’m buried low in the first round.
           For grins and giggles, here’s a breakdown of which positions I would take in each round if I landed the third pick in a snake style, 12-team draft.

  1. Tier 1 RB
  2. Tier 2 RB
  3. Tier 2 WR
  4. Tier 2 or 3 WR
  5. Tier 2 QB
  6. Tier 3 TE
  7. WR or RB
  8. WR or RB
  9. WR or RB
  10. WR or RB
  11. WR or RB
  12. WR or RB
  13. WR or RB
  14. DEF
  15. K (if you take one any sooner than this, remember, you're a dumbass)
          The most important thing with fantasy football? Have fun! It’s way too unpredictable and luck driven to get emotionally invested in. Fantasy football may be the simplest fantasy sport, but it’s also the most fun on game day. Good luck in your drafts, and have a fun fantasy season.

No comments:

Post a Comment